REVIEW GUIDELINES
Your review is due in class Monday, April 5, and should contain the following elements:

1) A letter to the editor that summarizes the most important aspects of your reiew. This should be a candid summary; it will not be seen by the author.

2) A rating sheet. Download here.

3) Comments for the author. Remember that these comments will be seen by the author. Please keep your comments constructive.

4) The copy of the manuscript including any notes that you made during the review process. Most of these notes should be summarized in your comments, but you can include additional commentary as well.